politics photography identity security psychology communication hosting friends database macos messaging stuff dropbox privacy tunisia tags snails photographers editor google history vim music misc postprocessing blot neurology social maps markdown brazil self github self-ignorance openmeta hdr sensel data neighborhood economics travel poetry hierarchy online-storage C1P stories capitalism beer photos zones books democrats philosophy opensource isp annotation spreadsheets photoshop gmail wifi peacecorps apercus culture from-the-back religion camus math Lr bicycles nyc color costco fun records json dynamic-range gradient zabouti sharpening home windows art 60s medical french git curves geeky racism language 1password
2021-05-06

A Monument to the Union Victory

A good friend of mine asks on Facebook:

Why aren’t there Union victory monuments or monuments to abolitionists?

This question reminded me of the monuments at Gettysburg, where I was struck by the contrast between the monuments erected by the Union and Confederate states. In general the Confederate monuments were larger and more warlike, the sort of thing you’d expect from the victors. The victors, on the other hand, generally erected more sober monuments naming the soldiers who had died and expressing sadness at the war’s terrible toll.

Then I remembered a monument at the US Capitol. It might not even be a monument, it is so understated, on a par with the Vietnam memorial. Only its placement tells you how important it is:

Placement of the Memorial
ALT

I remember wandering near the statue of the horseman years ago and being moved by its majesty and sense of tragedy. US Grant, perhaps our greatest general, is sitting on top of his horse, but the horse is not rearing up for battle and the man atop is not saluting his triumph.

Closeup of the Memorial
ALT

Now, years later, having listened to American Ulysses, Ron White’s biography of Grant, I think of him as a truly great leader and human being. His life was so rich and complex that I won’t try to explain what makes him great. It’s clear from this simple monument that our country felt the same as I do.


Previous post
Quotations Why does Butler prefer to write in this teasing, exasperating way? The style is certainly not unprecedented. Some precincts of the continental
Next post
The Great 2021 Gasoline Shortage – As I recall, the Fabulous Furry Freak Brothers used to say Beer will get you through times of no gasoline better than gasoline will get you